Monolithic Culture: How Siloed Thinking Crushes Creativity

by Dec 29, 2014Articles

The end of the year usually brings good cheer, solemn reflection and future planning. Countless think pieces give us the obligatory “Best Of” list in music, film and culture in general. The end of 2014 brought a special gift to those of us who are cultural voyeurs. We were treated to the release of a multitude of hacked communication between executives at Sony, which gave us an inside (though illegal) look at the machinations of this giant. We were now privy to movie superstar salaries, profanity laced emails arguing the merit of bankable stars like Angelina Jolie, Kevin Hart and Leonardo DiCaprio. The gossip, the egos, the ridiculous budget demands for likely future flops (yes, we’re looking at you Angelina, Cleopatra is a phenomenally bad idea) were on full display. What was also on full display was racially insensitive comments between Sony CEO Amy Paschal and producer Scott Rudin as the speculated on what type of movies President Obama might enjoy. Listing films with either predominately black themes or cast, such as 12 Years A Slave, Think Like A Man or Django Unchained one can only marvel at both the laziness and the tone deaf nature of this exchange. Many used this episode to discuss the hypocrisy of a Hollywood establishment that is often perceived as a bastion of liberal politics. Instead, I think it is more endemic of a belief system that permeates not only our creative institutions but traditional business as well. Culture is viewed as a monolithic whole, with little nuance, or attention paid to the margins. In short, silos are created to help decision makers produce better results but instead they segregate and ultimately crush creativity.

The Sony emails are important as they gave us insight into an off color moment in the lives of two very powerful people in Hollywood. These people are at the top of the decision-making food chain and help shape popular culture in a significant way. Their comments, made in jest and in their minds privately, are informative as it clues us into bias. They regard the taste and preferences of African American consumers to be monolithic in mature. The taste of President Obama, by the virtue of his blackness means he must prefer films that represent his “silo”. More dangerously it assumes that he (and by extension all of us) can’t like BOTH the aforementioned films as well as others across a range of themes. In essence, you can’t like 12 Years A Slave and Kevin Hart AND also enjoy Paul Thomas Anderson films and likely Oscar nominated Best Picture Birdman. These ideas should not be in conflict but in the viewpoints of those who have a monolithic cultural bias they most certainly are. Monolithic cultural bias is an “either/or” decision model. You have to either be one thing or another; you can’t be an amalgamation of many things. Your interest, viewpoints and value system have to fit into one neat silo or another. This is lazy and results in missed opportunities for those who wish to thrive in the cultural space.

When you lump people into predetermined silos you miss important cultural opportunities that exist on both the margins and by recognizing nuance. The margin is the driver of change and in fresh perspectives. Failing to acknowledge a margin exist much less to see it assures you miss sub cultures and authentic cultural expression in their infancy. Lack of recognition of nuance is ultimately a lack of recognition of diversity. Rather than be creative and take a chance to identify the value that lies with diverse communities it is easier keep doing the same thing. Clinging to these notions of monolithic culture strangles creativity at the root. I am not certain change can come at the top of these organizations, though it definitely needs to. At least we have an opportunity to question the assumptions of monolithic culture bias and advocate for more diverse and nuanced perspectives.

RSS The Deep Dive

  • Episode 205: Running Out of Everything w/ Peter S. Goodman November 21, 2024
    Philip welcomes global economic correspondent for The New York Times Peter S. Goodman to the show to discuss his new book How The World Ran out of Everything: Inside the Global Supply Chain. In this conversation they look at the fragility of the global supply chain and what it means for our long term economic, […]
  • Episode 204: Making New Worlds w/ Aida Mariam Davis November 7, 2024
    Philip welcomes writer/scholar Aida Mariam Davis to discuss her latest book Kindred Creation: Parables and Paradigms for Freedom. In their wide ranging conversation they explore how building ties of kinship and surfacing varying knowledge systems can make new worlds possible. The Drop – The segment of the show where Philip and his guest share tasty […]
  • Episode 203: Leadership & Making a Masterpiece w/ Charles Spinosa October 31, 2024
    Philip welcome Charles Spinosa, author Leadership As Masterpiece Creation to The Deep Dive. In their conversation, they discuss what it means to be a leader, how we organize ourselves and what it looks like when masterpiece language and thinking applies itself to our work. The Drop – The segment of the show where Philip and […]
  • Episode 202: Solving the Climate Crisis w/ John Berger October 24, 2024
    In this episode of The Deep Dive, Philip welcomes John Berger, the author of Solving the Climate Crisis. In this conversation, they examine the growing climate emergency against ongoing global movements to stem the tide and reverse course. The Drop – The segment of the show where Philip and his guest share tasty morsels of […]
  • Episode 201: Wrestling with Gender & Leadership w/ Susan Madsen October 17, 2024
    Philip welcomes researcher and author Susan Madsen to the show. In their conversation, they explore her new book focused on gender and leadership and dissect the consistent myths and impediments to women led leadership. The Drop – The segment of the show where Philip and his guest share tasty morsels of intellectual goodness and creative […]
  • Episode 200: The Resilience Myth w/ Soraya Chemaly September 12, 2024
    On episode 200, Philip welcome author and activist Soraya Chemaly to the show. They discuss her latest book The Resilience Myth and how our belief systems on resilience, grit and strength impact us as individuals and as a society. The Drop – The segment of the show where Philip and his guest share tasty morsels […]
  • Episode 199: Black Scare/Red Scare w/ Dr. Charisse Burden-Stelly August 22, 2024
    Philip welcomes Charisse Burden-Stelly author of Black Scare//Red Scare to the show. In their conversation, they examine the historical connection between the criminalization and fear mongering in radical politics through the lens of anti-communist and anti-Black thinking and policy. The Drop – The segment of the show where Philip and his guest share tasty morsels […]
  • Episode 198: End of the World w/ Jon Mills August 8, 2024
    Philip welcomes Jon Mills the author of End of The World: Civilization and Its Fate. In their conversation, they discuss whether or not extinction is an inevitable event and what are the underlying conditions of a future that seems more precarious. The Drop – The segment of the show where Philip and his guest share […]
  • Episode 197: St. Augustine & the Christian Master w/ Matthew Elia August 1, 2024
    Philip welcomes Matthew Elia to discuss his new book, The Problem of the Christian Master. Taking a turn into the theological we discuss how St. Augustine’s relationship with the master/slave duality has impacted modern Christian thinking. We dissect how this connects to Black Studies, liberation politics and on the other side of the equation Christian […]
  • Episode 196: Out of Time w/ Colin Strong July 11, 2024
    Philip welcomes Colin Strong to the show where they discuss his book Out of Time. In their conversation, they tackle the meaning of time, literally and figuratively, and how it impacts how we know and understand our place in the world. The Drop – The segment of the show where Philip and his guest share […]