Mark Zuckerberg’s Memo Isn’t Leadership
It was recently reported that Facebook Founder, Mark Zuckerberg released a letter dealing with intolerant behavior on behalf of his employees. Apparently, within Facebook HQ has a wall where employees are encouraged to share thoughts, ideas or general musings for public consumption. “Black Lives Matters”, the hashtag turned social movement, was among the material written on the wall. Unfortunately to some faction of Facebook employees this was not well received and the words were either erased or replaced with the demeaning counter argument of “All Lives Matter”. Mr. Zuckerberg having already released an internal memo to deal with and denounce these incidents only to have them continue upped the ante in a tersely worded letter to employees. You can read it in full here.
The letter was positively received as evidence of Mark Zuckerberg “getting it”. He was applauded for his clear and unequivocal support for a tolerant work place environment. He also scored points by making a concise case for Black Lives Matter and its relevance given the historical and current social climate. All of these things are good but they are not positions to be lauded. Nor are they examples of visionary leadership.
Peter F. Drucker sums it up perfectly “Management is doing things right; leadership is doing the right things.”
What Mr. Zuckerberg demonstrates is good managerial skills (with a healthy dose of understanding the power of public relations), nothing more and nothing less. As the Founder and CEO of one of the most highly visible companies in the world it is Managerial 101 to confront any issues of workplace intolerance head on. In this respect he does 100% the correct thing. His messaging is clear and leaves no grey area for the offending employees. But, this is NOT an example of leadership, least of all visionary leadership as many have cited. In short, Mr. Zuckerberg is doing what he is “supposed to do” and as Chris Rock says I can’t give him too much credit for that. Facebook exists within an industry that has rightly come under fire for its shocking lack of diversity. Only 2% of the Facebook total workforce is African American and 4% is Hispanic. Leadership in this context would be an aggressive push to diversify Facebook ranks throughout the organization. Recruiting, hiring and retaining a diverse workforce would prove that Facebook is inclusive in both word and action. The right thing, the visionary leadership thing, is to put forth actionable plans designed to upend the status quo. It is no longer enough to give lip service to diversity while not making concerted efforts to address inclusion. Mr. Zuckerberg is a great manager but we’re still waiting for the leader to emerge as it pertains to diversity and inclusion.
The Deep Dive
- Episode 190: Combee, Harriet Tubman & Black Freedom w/ Dr. Edda L. Fields-Black May 9, 2024Philip welcomes Dr. Edda L. Fields-Black to discuss her new book , COMBEE: Harriet Tubman, the Combahee River Raid, and Black Freedom during the Civil War. In their conversation they explore the historical impact of enslaved Blacks on the wealth creation of the South and the legacy of Harriet Tubman in the fight against slavery […]
- Episode 189: The AI Dilemna w/ Juliette Powell & Sean Gayle May 2, 2024Philip welcomes long time friends and deep thinkers Juliette Powell & Sean Gayle to the show. In our conversation we discuss Juliette’s book The AI Dilemna: 7 Principles for Responsible Technology. Collectively we engage to parse and dissect the way AI and Big Tech are moving in the world of culture and society. The Drop […]
- Episode 188: Cultural Intelligence for Marketers w/ Dr. Anastasia Karklina Gabriel April 25, 2024Philip welcomes 2x guest Dr. Anastasia Karklina Gabriel back to The Deep Dive to discuss the release of her first book: Cultural Intelligence for Marketers. In their conversation they discuss cultural fluency, the multiplicity of identity, and whether marketers are ready to embrace cultural intelligence. The Drop – The segment of the show where Philip […]
- Episode 187: Everest Inc & Climbing Culture w/ Will Cockrell April 18, 2024Philip welcomes Will Cockrell climber/author to The Deep Dive to discuss how book Everest Inc. In their conversation, they explore the sometimes harsh realities behind the growing climbing industry and how Mt. Everest in particular has become the epicenter of the global climbing rush. The Drop – The segment of the show where Philip and […]
- Episode 186: When the World Is A Bezzle w/ Cory Doctorow April 11, 2024Philip welcomes prolific writer and thinker Cory Doctrow to the show where they discuss two of Cory’s latest books, The Bezzle and The InternetCon as well as the general “enshittification” of our institutions. The Drop – The segment of the show where Philip and his guest share tasty morsels of intellectual goodness and creative musings. […]
- Episode 185: Hodge Podge, Gaps & Cracks w/ Dan Hill April 4, 2024Philip welcomes Dan Hill, Director, Melbourne School of Design to the show and they take a rambling journey through the worlds of architecture, design, music and all the gaps and cracks they can manage. The Drop – The segment of the show where Philip and his guest share tasty morsels of intellectual goodness and creative […]
- Episode 184: They Called It Peace w/ Lauren Benton March 21, 2024Philip welcomes historian and author Lauren Benton to the show to discuss her latest book They Called it Peace: Worlds of Imperial Violence. In their conversation, they explore how empire, small wars and plunder are key elements of how we think about peace. The Drop – The segment of the show where Philip and his […]
- Episode 183: Resisting Racial Capitalism w/ Ida Danewid March 14, 2024Philip welcomes lecturer and author Ida Danewid to the show to discuss her work Resisting Racial Capitalism. In their conversation, they explore Ida’s scholarship and how it confronts the way we think of racial capitalism and challenge our current governing structures and organizations. The Drop – The segment of the show where Philip and his […]
- Episode 182: Design Social Change w/ Lesley-Ann Noel March 7, 2024Philip welcomes design scholar Lesley-Ann Noel back to The Deep Dive to discuss her latest book Design Social Change. In their conversation they discuss how design intentionally done can be a catalyst for driving social change. The Drop – The segment of the show where Philip and his guest share tasty morsels of intellectual goodness […]
- Episode 181: Disneyland on the Mountain w/ Greg Glasgow & Kathryn Mayer February 29, 2024Philip welcomes authors Greg Glasgow & Kathryn Mayer to discuss their book Disneyland on the Mountain. Their conversation examines Disney at a remarkable time in its history and how its ambition helped launch the modern environmental movement. The Drop – The segment of the show where Philip and his guest share tasty morsels of intellectual […]